Data

  • surveys
    • careful with personal identification
    • form brackets rather than actual values less identifiable
    • e.g.
  • company data
    • data which the company has anyway
    • e.g. amount of sick days
  • empirical data
    • e.g. heart rate, skin conductivity

What to measure

  • control group vs treatment group

When to measure

  • before vs after experiment

Objectives

  • measurement of changes
    • across time and situation
    • e.g. attitudes
  • Operationalization
    • operational definition may vary
    • take definition into account
  • conclusions should rely on many studies
    • not just one, not just your own

Participants

  • anything with a social flavor in the experiment will be different in a different region
  • practical problem: there is little variance with the participants
  • always take into account if the participants of a study are relevant for your context

Results

Potential Solutions for Missing Counterfactuals

  • Propensity Score Matching (PSM)
    • matching 1:1 results from treatment and control group which have similar values
    • e.g. in a sport study match athletes by sport and weight to analyse performance, could not compare a runner with a sumo fighter otherwise
  • Instrumental Variables (IV)
    • variable is correlated with the treatment, not with the effect of the treatment
      • difference in treatment strength
    • e.g. giving different doses of the same medicine to people in a medical study
  • Regression Discontinuity Design (RDD)
    • clear cutoff across e.g. time but with very little difference
      • have to make sure that cutoff is not resulting in difference in sample
    • e.g. difference between birthday at 31st August and 1st September is just 1 day - but one gets in the school system directly with 31st Aug and before, 1st Sep and later need to wait for next year
    • e.g. Cross Border Deforestation
  • Difference in Difference (DiD)
    • classic medical experiment structure - 2 samples, 1 receives treatment, 1 doesn’t
      • difference between treatment and placebo group is effect
    • samples must be similar/equal by being large enough (n>40 each)
      • significance

Experiment Types