Sustainability Reporting for Rittersport: IRO Analysis
by Group 5 - Farkas Benedek, Horvat Zellhofer Paulina, Meixner Benjamin
Introduction
This report presents the findings of an Impacts, Risks, and Opportunities (IRO) analysis conducted for a chocolate producer, focusing on sustainability matters. The analysis assesses the materiality of various environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors, identifies key risks and opportunities, and highlights stakeholder perspectives. The objective is to provide a comprehensive overview that informs strategic sustainability initiatives and reporting efforts.
Materiality Assessment
The materiality assessment employed a double materiality approach, evaluating both the financial implications and the broader environmental and social impacts of each sustainability matter. Key areas identified include climate change, water and marine resources, biodiversity, resource use and raw materials, workforce conditions, supply chain practices, community impact, consumer relations, business conduct, and management control.
Climate change and resource use emerged as significant factors, each rated highly in both impact and financial materiality. These areas are critical due to their direct influence on operational costs, supply chain stability, and long-term viability. Water management and biodiversity also hold considerable importance, given the chocolate producer’s dependence on water-intensive processes and the ecological footprint of cocoa cultivation.
Conversely, certain areas such as management and control, while still relevant, were assessed with slightly lower materiality ratings, reflecting their supportive role in the overall sustainability framework. Some matters, like specific aspects of governance, received minimal to informational rankings, indicating lower immediate impact but recognizing their foundational importance.
Materiality Table
| Matter | Impact Materiality | Risk | Opportunity | Financial Materiality (R+O) | Double Materiality (Combined) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E1 Climate Change | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 4 |
| E3 Water & Marine Resources | 4 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
| E4 Biodiversity | 2 | 3 | 2 | 5 | |
| E6 Resource Use and Raw Materials | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 4 |
| S1 Own Workforce | 3 | 2 | 2 | 3 | |
| S2 Workers in the Value Chain | 5 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| S3 Affected Communities | 3 | 2 | 2 | 3 | |
| S4 Consumers and End-users | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 4 |
| G1 Business Conduct | 4 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
| G2 Management and Control | 2 | 3 | 2 | 3 | |
| 5: critical, 4: significant, 3: important, 2: informational, 1: minimal |
Key Impacts, Risks, and Opportunities
The analysis identified several interconnected groups of impacts, risks, and opportunities:
-
Climate and Environmental: Significant greenhouse gas emissions and high water usage present both environmental impacts and financial risks, such as increased costs from carbon pricing and regulatory fines. Opportunities include investing in renewable energy and implementing water-efficient technologies.
-
Supply Chain Management: Sustainable sourcing and fair labor practices are crucial for maintaining a reliable supply chain. Risks include supply chain disruptions due to unethical practices, while opportunities lie in building responsible partnerships and innovating eco-friendly materials.
-
Social Responsibility: Ensuring fair wages, safe working conditions, and community development are vital for employee satisfaction and local support. Risks involve potential labor disputes and loss of consumer trust, whereas opportunities include enhanced brand loyalty and community goodwill.
-
Governance and Compliance: Ethical business conduct and effective risk management are essential for mitigating legal penalties and reputational damage. Opportunities include building a trustworthy brand and attracting sustainability-focused investors.
Stakeholder Perspectives
Engaging with key stakeholders revealed diverse priorities and insights:
- Consumers prioritize ethically sourced products, health and safety, and transparent labeling, expressing willingness to support sustainable practices financially.
- Retail Customers demand consistent quality, sustainability certifications, and transparent supply chains to align with their own CSR goals.
- Employees seek fair wages, safe working conditions, and opportunities for development, highlighting the importance of a supportive workplace environment.
- Supply Chain Partners emphasize the need for sustainable sourcing and long-term partnerships, with a focus on compliance and collaboration.
- Cocoa Producers require fair pricing, support for sustainable farming, and resilience against climate impacts to ensure their livelihoods.
- Financial Providers focus on sustainability performance, risk management, and transparency, influencing investment decisions.
- Local Communities seek positive impacts from business operations, including access to education, healthcare, and employment opportunities.
- Regulators and NGOs stress compliance with laws, ethical sourcing, and active participation in sustainability initiatives.
Supporting Cocoa Producing Communities
A critical aspect of the sustainability strategy is the support of cocoa-producing communities. These communities are often vulnerable to exploitation due to economic disparities and environmental challenges. Ensuring fair wages, providing access to education and healthcare, and investing in sustainable farming practices are essential measures. By fostering strong relationships and offering capacity-building initiatives, the chocolate producer can mitigate risks of social unrest and supply chain disruptions. Additionally, supporting infrastructure development and promoting gender equality within these communities enhances overall resilience and sustainability, ensuring that cocoa producers are not only protected but also empowered to thrive in a changing global market.
Conclusion
The IRO analysis underscores the multifaceted nature of sustainability for a chocolate producer, highlighting the interplay between environmental stewardship, social responsibility, and robust governance. By addressing high-materiality areas such as climate change, water management, and supply chain sustainability, the company can mitigate significant risks and capitalize on emerging opportunities. Engaging with stakeholders provides valuable insights that inform strategic decisions and enhance the company’s sustainability reporting. Emphasizing support for cocoa-producing communities ensures ethical practices and long-term supply chain stability, fostering a sustainable and equitable business model.
Simulating Shareholders with GPT
We simulated Interviews with GPT-4o mini to have a wider data pool available for our analysis. Here we have summarized our interviews with different stakeholders.
Consumers
- Demand for ethically sourced and fair-trade products
- Concerns about product health and safety
- Preference for transparent labeling and sourcing information
- Desire for environmentally friendly packaging
- Willingness to pay premium for sustainable products
Customers (Retailers)
- Requirement for consistent supply of high-quality cocoa
- Interest in sustainability certifications (e.g., Fair Trade, Rainforest Alliance)
- Need for transparency in supply chain practices
- Demand for environmentally friendly packaging options
- Preference for partners with strong CSR initiatives
Employees
- Importance of fair wages and safe working conditions
- Desire for training and development opportunities
- Interest in company’s sustainability and CSR efforts
- Need for a diverse and inclusive workplace
- Concerns about job security and company’s long-term sustainability
Supply Chain Partners
- Requirement for sustainable sourcing practices
- Interest in long-term partnerships and stability
- Need for compliance with environmental and social standards
- Demand for transparency and traceability in supply chain
- Opportunities for collaboration on sustainability initiatives
Cocoa Producers
- Concerns about fair pricing and market stability
- Need for support in adopting sustainable farming practices
- Interest in training and capacity building
- Desire for access to better infrastructure and resources
- Concerns about climate change impacting cocoa yields
Other Raw Material Producers
- Interest in sustainable sourcing of materials like sugar, packaging
- Need for efficient resource use and waste management
- Desire for fair trade practices and equitable pricing
- Concern about regulatory compliance and environmental impact
- Opportunities for innovation in sustainable materials
Financial Providers (Investors, Banks)
- Focus on company’s sustainability performance and reporting
- Interest in risk management related to environmental and social factors
- Desire for transparency and accountability in governance
- Consideration of sustainability in investment decisions
- Opportunities for funding sustainable projects and growth initiatives
Local Communities
- Impact of farming practices on local livelihoods
- Access to education and healthcare facilities
- Employment opportunities and fair labor practices
- Environmental preservation and reduced pollution
- Support for community development projects
Regulators and Governments
- Compliance with environmental and social regulations
- Enforcement of labor laws and fair trade standards
- Incentives for sustainable business practices
- Monitoring of supply chain transparency and ethical sourcing
- Collaboration on sustainability initiatives and reporting standards
NGOs and Advocacy Groups
- Promotion of fair trade and ethical sourcing
- Monitoring of environmental and social impact
- Advocacy for workers’ rights and elimination of child labor
- Partnership opportunities for sustainability projects
- Demand for transparency and accountability in reporting
Shareholders
- Interest in long-term financial performance and sustainability
- Demand for robust risk management strategies
- Desire for transparent and regular sustainability reporting
- Support for initiatives that enhance brand reputation
- Focus on governance practices and ethical business conduct